Reaching a verdict

Can We Write Your Essay?

Ace your next assignment with help from a professional writer. Free proofreading and copy-editing included.

  • After the Crown and defence make their cases, it is time for the judge and/or jury to reach a decision about the guilt of the accused
  • Charge to the jury: judge reviews the law applying to the case, how certain evidence should be weighed, there needs to be intent etc.

Deliberation

  • Jury leaves the courtroom to discuss and find innocence/guilt of the accused
  • Determine the facts of the case (judge’s job is to determine the law)
  • Can ask to see evidence again
  • Throw out evidence that’s not believable
  • Judge the importance of the remaining evidence
  • Ex. Is the accused of 1st degree, 2nd degree murder OR manslaughter
    • Hung jury: when a jury cannot reach a decision: the trial must be re-set and re-done
    • Foreman (head juror) reads the verdict in court
    • R v G (R.M.)

Sentencing

  • Factors in sentencing: can include
  • Criminal code
  • Precedents
  • Charter of Rights/Freedoms
  • Accused’s criminal record
  • Pre-trial custody
  • Public opinion
  • Victim impact statement

Steps in sentencing

  • Pre sentence report: which describes the offender’s situation (lifestyle, prior convictions)
  • Crown/defence lawyers may respond to sentencing and call witnesses, have the offender make a statement

Imposing a sentence

  • Power of the judge: can determine the actual amount of months/years the sentence is to be
  • Ex. Maximum 25 yrs: judge determines the actual length of time
    • This is where the multiple factors come into effect – impact statements, will of Parliament: government’s stance on sentencing for certain crimes (length, time in jail/alternatives)
READ:
Sentencing, Appeals, and Prison

Goals of sentencing

  • Deterrence:
  • Sentencing should keep people from wanting to re-offend, and reflect the society’s lack of tolerance for breaking the law
  • Specific deterrence: to not commit the specific crime again
  • General deterrence: all citizens should not commit that specific crime
  • Rehabilitation:
  • The act of re socializing an offender back into society.
  • Job training
  • Counselling
  • Supervised parole
  • Reduce recidivism: returning to prison/committing new crimes
  • Retribution:
  • Not a sentencing objective
  • Supreme Court: “an objective…that properly reflects the moral culpability of the offender…the intentional risk taking of the offender, the harm caused by the offender, and the character of the offender’s conduct
  • Segregation:
  • To keep offenders from society
  • Currently, Canadian law is focusing on alternative methods to reduce the number of people in prison, though for serious crimes, prison is the only option
  • Punishment has to fit the crime
  • The most severe punishments are handed down to those who are most offensive to society
  • Mitigating circumstances: lessen the responsibility of the offender
  • Aggravating circumstances: increase the responsibility of the offender

Restorative Justice

  • Restorative justice: focuses on healing relationships – the offender, victim, the community
  • Used within the Aboriginal community
  • Sentencing circles: brings all parties together to express their opinions and determine a sentence
  • Healing circles: to resolve the conflict between victim and offender
  • Releasing circles: community, parole board, offender meet to prepare a successful return to the community

Can We Help with Your Assignment?

Let us do your homework! Expert writers in all subject areas are available and will meet your assignment deadline.

guest
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments